Five Things I Hate About Being An Uchi Deshi

1. I hate it when I compare myself to others–particularly extremely talented individuals. It makes me feel inadequate and gives me a bad attitude on the mat.

2. I hate taking the last class of the day. Especially if I have trained hard in the ones before.

3. I hate getting colds all the time. having a sore throat and a runny nose makes practice very difficult. Plus people don’t like training with you when you sound like a fog horn and dirty tissues fall out of your gi when they throw you.

4. I hate it when the person you are training with resists your technique so they have an excuse to correct you.

5. I hate it when personal matters affect my ability to concentrate in class.

Published
Categorized as Aikido

131 comments

  1. Ok, so there was this chick who would wear a bikini top under her gi instead of a shirt or something. So whenever it was her turn to throw, she would carefully watch the guy’s eyes, and then— WHAM!

  2. You’ve described atemi.

    Uke was distracted, his balance was taken and the technique successfully performed.

    Atemi can be anything, so long as the intent is there to cause uke to lose balance. Even in a martial context, it doesn’t have to be a strike.

    Ever wonder why the gunslingers in those great westerns would wait for just..the…right moment to draw their pistols?

  3. what judo school is this?

    she could throw me all day long…

    and we all know you must wait for the tumbleweed to brush by followed by that western style flute playing..THEN you can draw…

  4. Who saw “Lucky Number Sleven”? Sounds like a Kansas City Shuffle more than an Atemi. Since the choice in undergarment does not actually cause some one to shift their center (unless they go for it…). With most atemis that I know of, the response causes Uke to loose their balance, I don’t see how the top would, most people would stop and stare, the oposite response of an atemi, right?

    You are also asumeing she is attractive, dark knight. She might not be, which might make it more destracting than an attractive woman in the same situation. That is everyone’s biggest fear, to be laughed at publically.

  5. incogneto, balance is not just physical. You can lose your balance, for example, by the mere prospect of being *asked* to attack a shihan. Believe me, I know.

    Shifting your eyes, losing concentration, is *more* than enough.

    Tell you what, let’s try this out. We’ll get two bokken, and you look away for a moment. We’ll see how that turns out for you.

  6. Or, to carry your analogy, you stare at, say, my wrist, instead of looking at my shoulders, stance, and your surroundings. (i.e. you limit your awareness, and don’t maintain zanshin).

    *Thwak*

  7. In the context of the example given by grasshopper, there is no attack or intent once they get distracted by the choice in wardrobe, though. They no longer wish to attack, their intent is shifted to other thoughts… At that point, anything you do to take their ballance is you initiating an attack. At that point it ceases to be Aikido and becomes Judo, which has no atemis. From my point of veiw, a lot of what makes Aikido unique from other similar art forms like jujutsu and judo is the intent to restore balance to the situation. If you have stoped their aggretion towards you, you can’t instigate another conflict without it becoming something else. This is why Aikido doesn’t use any kind of dummy or human like object to practice on, it is always interaction between 2 or more people. We don’t train to throw sand bags or dead weight, which is what the uke has turned into with his focus away from attacking you. Once the aggressor has given up, an Aikikai can’t attack without throwing away the moral code that seperates his school from Jujutsu or Judo.

    My only arguement for this not being an atemi, is that (using your 2 boken example) one person drops his sword and turns to walk away and the other person strikes him. The intent to attack is gone, and the situation is at balance.

  8. yea because when i break your nose or slam the ridge of my hand into your temple, you are distracted…

  9. We don’t debate, we lovingly argue in a friendly way. I like to argue and Jerry is convenced that he is always right. It just works out good for all of us. This is actually about Aikido, so I think it has a lot more validity than the whole watchmen thing….

  10. incogneto,

    1. You are incorrect regarding your claim: “Anything you do taking their balance is you initiating an attack.” That’s a fundamental misunderstanding of uke’s role.

    2. You are *remarkably* incorrect about Aikido transforming into Judo. 😯

    3. Your claim that Aikido always involves 2 or more people is mistaken, but understandable, given your experience. Aikido, like all budo, is training of the self. Our uke, ultimately, is our own ego. Our practice on the mat is really just prologue.

    4. Are you certain that the “moral” code of Aikido is superior or even unique vis-a-vis other budo? On what experience do you base this on?

    5. You’ve mischaracterized my bokken example.

    Other than that, and the incorrect use of the term “Aikikai”, I agree with your rebuttal. 😉

  11. Also, I’m not always right. Far from it. In fact, during my class today, I demonstrated my recent changes to my sankyo pin, and emphasized the importance of having an “empty cup”. Too bad you missed it. A good lesson for you, maybe?

    I will admit, however, that I’m *almost* always right when discussing Aikido with a newly minted 4th kyu, who (perhaps) thinks he knows more than his technique warrants? 😉

  12. To elaborate a bit on #1, when uke attacks she is already off-balance. Or, to be more precise, the attack is the physical manifestation of an unbalanced personality (at least at that moment).

    It is a subtle but important distinction. A balanced personality has no desire to cause harm to another. When uke attacks, nage is given a gift–the chance to bring an unbalanced personality back into harmony. The physical aspect of the technique is incidental.

    So when nage takes uke’s balance, he is not attacking.

  13. One final point, regarding your comparison to Judo. Who says that Judo has no atemi? (Certainly not me.) And who says atemi needs to be a strike, anyway?

  14. Incogneto, you totally misinterpreted what Jerry was saying in the bokken example. He did not say one lowered his sword and walked away. He said one looked away for a moment. The intent to attack is still there. This is similar to the old trick of “Look! Your shoe is untied!”

    Since you guys have made an attempt to go deeper into what atemi is I thought I would put my two cents in. We are accustomed to atemi being a response to an initial attack by uke but that doesn’t always have to be the case. I feel the attack begins with nage’s interpretation of when the intent is felt from uke. Many times we practice having nage begin a movement towards uke to force his hand (so to speak) as in morote-tori. You wouldn’t really do this to someone who you felt was non-threatening otherwise you would be the attacker at that point. With a bikini top, you might be distracted whether the person is good-looking or not because your focus is diverted. Or when attacking a shihan you might change your focus from giving a committed attack to hoping you don’t get hurt. These can be construed as internal atemis.

    I have seen a high ranking instructor–just when uke is lifting his arm to strike–yell out, and uke stops in his tracks. Either way you are off-balanced whether it was by a strike from nage (verbal or physical) or you did it to yourself in your own brain. Then again one might say this is only a distraction not an atemi. Then you have to define atemi at this point. Is it just a physical strike or can it be something else?

    For you younger aikidoists, I appreciate your enthusiasm about Aikido and all the aspects that you discuss. Keep it up. It is common to get opinionated early on in Aikido training. I think, however, you can learn from your sempais if you listen more and try to understand what they are saying instead of establishing your own opinions at this point.

    Nothing is black and white and nothing is as it always seems. Training is the most important thing. Everything else will take care of itself in due time. Then again that is just my opinion.

  15. Dark Knight,

    In the context of a strike, an atemi is only effective insofar as uke believes that unless he moves he will be struck and injured.

    This means that the strike must be committed, and targeted towards a vulnerable point. Uke, seeing the impending strike, must respond, and thereby be interrupted in his attack.

    As you know, in my classes I point out uke’s vulnerable points (groin, choke, floating rib, elbow, etc.) in the context of a technique. The difficult part is uke having the awareness to understand his vulnerable position. As you’ve no doubt heard me say before, if uke moves into a vulnerable position unwittingly, nage should nonverbally correct uke by telegraphing the strike to the vulnerable body part.

    (I suspect this was not much of a problem in the old days when Aikido was reserved for students who had already attained a black belt in other martial arts. They already had a martial awareness about them.)

    Of course, the intent is not to cause uke harm with the strike. It is to disrupt uke’s center. But uke cannot know this, else the atemi loses its meaning.

    In kata training we thread the needle, so to speak, by uke acting as if the atemi were to cause injury. Otherwise, the learning process would be short circuited.

    I personally am of the belief that 90% of Aikido is atemi. Otherwise, the movements that we practice make very little sense.

  16. Oh, okay. In the context of Aikido, then, I think she means that it is important to keep an open mind while training.

  17. I don’t think I am making myself clear on this. I do agree that an atemi doesn’t have to be a physical strike, it can be internal as Jerry and sensei have said. I also think that it is fundamental in our artform that these nonphysical atemis are there. I do not agree that in the specific example of the judo bikini is an atemi in the sense of an Aikido atemi because her atemi ceases hostility on the part of the nage, then she attacks. In my mind, it seems to me that it is the same school of though that would say, “alright, you were right and I was wrong” only to have them strike the other person once their guard is lowered. That is how I see the situation in this point.

    I never said or meant to insinuate that Aikido ethics are better than any other martial art’s, but I was just saying they are differant and distinct. From what I understand from my conversations with those who did Judo and Jujutsu, the ethics and intent is one of the things that seperates the arts because they do have similar techinques. I do not claim to know much about Judo, just what I gathered from descusions with those that did, which may not know as much as they think for all I know, but I take it at face value.

    I have never seen, heard of, or experianced Aikido that was practiced without another person. This may very well be due to my own short comings as a 4th kyu, and I don’t presume to know more than any of my seniors. I have never seen a class in our school or in a seminar were everything in it did not lead to or was meant to be used in an interaction of 2 people. One is required to be the nage (the one devoted to subduing the uke without hurting them) in Aikido, which I can’t even begin to imagine how that is possible within oneself. I am not disagreeing with Jerry’s saying that it can’t be done, I would like an explanation on how it is possible, though.

  18. ps. I liked Sensei’s comments on the subject, maybe a guest blog?

    I also want to make it known, I do not try to rile people up. Part of the learning process is seeing the range of what is workable, as it were.

  19. How soon you forget, incogneto. 😉

    Some examples of Aikido you have performed, without a partner:

    Suburi practice,
    13 jo kata,
    The 8 count bokken kata we learned from DiAnne Sensei,
    The four and eight direction bokken exercise,
    etc.

    At Palm Beach Aikikai, weapons kata is a required part of their kyu (and shodan) tests. Saotome Sensei has an entire curriculum based on weapons kata.

    Don’t be so quick to say what is and isn’t Aikido! 🙂

  20. Star Trek….. the red enson dies during the away mission… brilliant!
    Uhura ordered a slusho from the bar tender in the begining… slusho was the futuristic soda company that The lead man from Cloverfield was going to go work for …eeeeEEEEeeee

  21. You’re not fooling anyone, incogneto and MM. We all know you are in league together!

    So, getting back to the topic at hand, incogneto, do you concede the point that you have practiced Aikido without a partner?

    I demand satisfaction! 😈

  22. Why, incogneto? Is your shame so great?

    I’m reminded of Scott Tenorman, and the vindication Cartman must have felt, at the chili con-carnival….

    Bwahahahaha!

  23. lol
    First off, I haven’t read alleged argument. I was told it started over a Judo chick in a bikini, and I rolled my eyes in disdain. lol

    Secondly, how is a bikini girl utemi more important than Star Trek? 0_0

    I love you both.

  24. Atemi does rank… male fantasies of being beat by a half naked girl doesn’t.

    reason for not wearing a bikini on the mat:

  25. Jerry likes to jump topics… The point of this was to see wheather or not a bikini counts as an atemi. But MM won’t let me argue about it anymore on the blog, so we’ll do it in person (where she’ll never know). I still have things to say… just tomorrow in class.

    As for Aikido by one’s lonesome… I concede nothing. I stand by my statement that I have yet to see it. Every kata, sword work, or weapons technique that I ever remember doing in class or at seminars was done with one or more partner. The 2nd kata of the 13 jo forms is a watershed because the uke is tsi-ing (not spelled right, I know). I have done this kata in Sensei’s class, Buck’s, Mike’s, and Jerry’s and they all do it with a partner. Other schools might do it, but I have never seen it done. I will not sit here and be the 4th kyu shihan who causes strife between Aikido schools, but it has not been stressed in this school… maybe for a reason? The only exercise I have ever seen done alone is stretches, which I don’t consider part of the practice. If you did consider the stretches to be an intracate part of Aikido, then I concede that point.

  26. four directionals can be done without a partner…

    walking around your house in aikido stances….

    putting yourself in nikkyo…

  27. I’m sorry, incogneto, but you’re wrong. To take the original example, nowhere did grassHopper state that the judoka ceased his attack. She merely stated that he was distracted. In fact, this is implied in the context. Judo matches don’t just stop. They continue until someone wins.

    This is the same result you want from a correctly applied atemi. Uke is interrupted in his attack, because nage has successfully taken his balance, but crucially does not give up. How often have I told you that just as nage is continually trying to affect uke’s center, uke must continue the attack throughout the technique to affect nage’s center? It is fundamental to what we’re trying to teach you.

    Regarding solo kata work, I really don’t know what to say. The eight count bokken kata, the four and eight direction bokken kata, and the 13 jo kata are performed individually. I practice these all the time at home, by myself. Yes, an uke is implied in the kata, but so what? They are designed to be practiced solo.

    Regarding the 13 jo kata specifically, none us teach it with a partner. None. If I had to hazard a guess, I’d say you are confusing the 13 jo kata with jo-tori, which is practiced in pairs. (I can say this with some certainty because Mike rarely teaches the 13 jo kata, while you state otherwise).

    (Just so you know, there are forms extant that include multiple uke’s with the jo kata, but these are somewhat non-standard. I’ve practiced that form rarely in my career. I haven’t–yet–taught it to you).

    Given my belief that you are confusing jo-tori with the 13 jo kata, I’m disregarding the next few sentences.

    By the way, the “stretches” are more correctly called “aiki-taiso”, and are considered part of the Aikido canon. (I am referring to the body movements that you often see in Buck’s class). In fact, the rowing exercise is, in my opinion, the emblematic Aikido exercise. Although we do not practice it with this intent, the movements are derived from Shinto practice, which informed much of the Founder’s Aikido.

    (No, grassHopper, none of us practice it with that intent. It is a warm-up only, to loosen the arms.)

  28. Actually, this little back and forth has been very enlightening. What it tells me is that I need to emphasize weapons work in my classes. I started doing so in my last class, but more needs to be done.

    So for that incogneto, domo arigato. 🙂

Comments are closed.