1st Kyu Test

The testing lasted about 2 and a half hours. There were 35 participants. I had to wait till the end, feeling bouts of nervousness and exhaustion the whole time. Everyone says I did beautifully though. I’m a little confused about my randori, however. I had no techniques in mind when I bowed to my uke’s. I just jumped up and charged the one on the edge. It was really short, maybe 30 seconds. Someone got it on tape. I just have to get it on YouTube somehow. Thanks for all your support.

Published
Categorized as Aikido

73 comments

  1. I spoke with Sensei–she is having a wonderful time at the Brevard Aikikai seminar with Zimmerman Sensei. She is learning a lot.

    I really wanted to go, but work obligations are keeping me in Jacksonville this weekend.

    Tonya, would it be possible to email us your test video? I want to see your randori.

  2. Congratulations Tonya! It looks like this is your year for great things going your way. I would like to see your test. Let me know when it is on YouTube.

  3. I am posting a link to a snip from the Seven Samurai that demonstrates in dramatic fashion a common bokken exercise from the dojo, here exemplifiying the effectiveness of irimi and the precise timing required. It also suggests the role confidence plays in determining the outcome of a confrontation. Watch it and internalize it. Kyai!

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DR45hbTSUIQ

  4. Are you certain that “confidence”, as a personality trait, was valued by the Samurai?

    I’d point out that the more confident swordsman in that scene, the one most attached to his ego, was killed.

    Surely you’ve heard the story of the tea master and the swordsman?

  5. Confidence and ego are not the same thing. The one who lost the duel was a victim of his ego (and inferior skill) while the victor was certain of his ability without any ego. The outcome was decided before the duel had taken place.

    Confidence is not a personality trait. It is a condition resulting from a belief in self. It is a learned and practiced behavior, not one you’re born with.

    It is hard to be successful in any indeavor unless you believe that you can do what you want to do. Tiger Woods wins as often as he does because he knows he can. He enters every tournament with the belief that he will win and never gives up. That attidude exudes as confidence, an assurance of his ability that strikes fear in his opponents.

    That’s not ego. Ego tries to get in the way of the natural self, the Id, the part that knows what to do without thinking, from which confidence comes.

    Regardless of your religion, the person of Jesus Christ as potrayed in the Bible offers a perfect example of humility without ego, yet proceeding with supreme confidence and authority.

    So back on the mat, we must learn through dedicated practice to be so confident in our Aikido (and our natural self) that when the time comes, victory is assured before the battle ensues.

  6. With apologies to the late, great David Carradine.

    *Puts down flute, tends fire*

    THE TEA MASTER AND THE SAMURAI

    Once upon a time in Japan, around the year double-aught three, a samurai and tea master were walking down a road, traveling in the opposite direction.

    As they crossed paths, the samurai, in a practically unfathomable display of generosity, gave the tea master the slightest of nods.

    The nod, however, was not returned.

    Now was it the intention of the tea master to insult the samurai? Or did he just fail to see the generous social gesture? And although the tea master tried to console the samurai on his breach of etiquette, the samurai was, ultimately, inconsolable.

    “Be back here tomorrow at dawn, so we can cross swords”

    Needless to say, the tea master was terrified. And although he was a master, he was a master of tea ceremony, which, on cursory examination, has nothing in common with swordplay, or fighting, or dying.

    The tea master frantically searched for a swordsman to teach him to fight before the fateful hour arrived. Lucky for him, he found what he was looking for–a retired sensei, who was willing to impart whatever skill he could.

    However, although he spent the next several hours practicing, under the increasingly exasperated tutelage of his instructor, the tea master did not improve in the slightest.

    In truth, he was lucky not to cut himself with his own weapon.

    “Enough!” yelled his instructor. “You are going to die tomorrow, and there is nothing you can do to prevent that.”

    The tea master, seeing the truth in his teacher’s words, became despondent.

    “You say you are a tea master. I’ve wasted this whole afternoon trying to teach you to fight. Show me something you CAN do. Make me some tea.”

    The tea master, having accepted his fate, took out his tea set and began the intricate ceremony.

    In so doing, the tea master was transformed. Where before his movements were jerky, now they were smooth. Where before he was terrifed of dying, now his mind was blank.

    “There! That’s it!” said his instructor. “Do not concern yourself with *yourself*. Tomorrow, when you meet your opponent, just cut and die.”

    And the tea master, being a master himself, understood.

    ****

    The next morning, at dawn, the samurai found the tea master on the road, as agreed. Smiling, he drew his sword, and then stopped. He saw in the tea master something he had not expected.

    The tea master, with his sword already above his head, was ready to die.

    The samurai moved closer, then farther away, then said:

    “Sir, you are truly a master swordsman. I did not know you were ronin, of the same rank as I. Please forgive my behavior.”

    And the tea master and samurai parted ways.

    ****

  7. I think the lesson of swordsmanship is the opposite of what you are saying. Rather than a belief in self, I think it is a letting go of self.

    Remember that irimi also means to invite death….

  8. If y’all are talking in point of Samurai sense of “self”, you are treading in my opinion upon a cultural aspect of feudal Japan that was at that forefront of how all social class and customs were built upon.
    In a feudal culture there is little emphasis placed upon the self. The entire structure of the society is dependent upon this social form. Feudalism for the common man is a Randian nightmare.
    There is a reason the country transitioned toward Buddhism so easily. (A faith based upon the idea that the self is the illusion, life is pain eternal, and that Karmatic balance is the only escape from it’s prideful delusions.)

    So basically, I think historically there was a great social stigma in Feudal Japan against the idea us Westerners thrive in; the idea of “Having Confidence in yourself”. Historically obedience was honored over a sense of self worth.
    As a Samurai, if you had a great deal of self esteem, self honor and a mentally healthy sense of self confidence you might not be so inclined to kill, die, or commit Seppuku so easily. You’d consider yourself a unique being with unique qualities. You’d morn your own death… a lord might find this highly undesirable.
    Also as the country transitioned to Buddhism the concept of the individual shrank more so. In a feudal land the needs of the many out weigh the needs of the one.(I love Star Trek!) The concept of self must be shrunken for the society to be successful and survive. Crops need planting and wars need fighting for each tiny kingdom within feudalism to be effective.A sense of “questionless” was ideal for getting business done, keeping boundaries safe and the common man alive.

    I’m not saying Samurai lacked a sense of self worth and confidence, there were Ronin, I just think it might not have been ideal for what the society in which Samurai lived as far as a mind set goes.

  9. Frankly, with my limited knowledge of Aikido, I just listen to the instructors. And the number one most repeated thing I hear is “The Entrance”, “It’s all about the entrance,” “Big entrance”, “about how you get into it”, “ENTER!” It has lead me to believe that the heart of Budo in an odd way is the entrance. It’s about entering the fight. I have a Samurai sword-play book at home depicting drawing of the oldest Samurai pictorial study guides. 100’s of pointers, dozens of photos. Not one pin is illustrated. Just entrances and kill blows. It has lead me to believe that for Samurai death is a footnote, not a final goal in life. The final goal for the Samurai might be the act of accepting and entering into the confrontation. It might be more simple, and far less climatic than self confidence. It’s almost anti-climatic. And that’s okay.

    It’s true no great thing is accomplished by one man without him believing in himself— I argue that the soldier mindset isn’t forged in men for the sake of accomplishment at all. But for the sake of doing. The embankment, not the destination.
    If you fret over the destination you care whether or not you travel there– what good a soldier is that? Leave the destination to itself, that’s not the soldiers home anyways. He wasn’t trained to bask in glory in kata training– he was trained in fight.

    It is about accepting what you are and your lot, indifferent to it’s objective circumstance maybe.

  10. I think you’re right, MM. The Japanese sword *is* Buddhist, more specifically Zen. This idea of “self-actualization”, at least in the sense that Buck refers to, is a Western conceit.

    You’re also right, I think, about the role of entrances in Aikido. Irimi is a fundamental concept, not just as technique, but also as “correct attitude.”

  11. Throughout my religious studies Buddhism’s concept of self is centered around the realization of the delusion. Existence was described as a dream by Buddha. I’m in no way a Buddhist myself, just stating what at least I’ve been made to understand about Buddhism throughout my college career in religion classes.

  12. It is a Western idea that the individual man has a purpose and is his own sort of glory as a unique being. He can accomplish anything he sets his mind to… but Eastern philosophy states that anything accomplished for the individual is vanities of vanities, futile in full, eternal pain. Your are working for the glory of something that in reality is not within eternal existence if it is for the delusional self.

    As a Christian that’s been the biggest obstacle for missions to the East. Christ’s blood offers a promise to of eternal life– that’s hell for a Buddhist. Life equals pain and suffering. Life to them is a painful never ending, reincarnating illusion from which they hope to wake from. Buddhists seek to end the cycle of birth, death and rebirth and wake up from this nonsense spiritually: spiritual death/rest is required. It is futile for them. Even Buddha is reincarnated in their faith…and he’s the most enlightened! If not even Buddha found rest, what hope is there for the common man?
    Christians hope to live forever– you see where the missionaries are having trouble.

  13. Well, the Samurai would have been hard pressed to find a philosophy more suited to their reality. Think about it-existence is suffering, the world is an illusion.

    BTW, where did you study Buddhism? At UNF or at seminary?

  14. Both. I studied world religions in bible college. I also had to take religious studies for my Associates. I’m actually in a philosophy course right now that’s making me do an essay contrasting and comparing the Buddhist philosophy towards “self ” vs. The Christian view of “self.” So, I had some fresh material for this blog. 😛

  15. While I do agree that Buddhists seek to eliminate self, and that does seem to be the ideal role of a samurai in feudal early society… there are some holes in your arguments that must be addressed. Not all students of Budo are Buddhist, most notably O’Sensei (for us at least). Shin Taoism was a strong religion throughout Japan’s history, and a lot of Samurai had affiliations with it rather than Buddhism… there was also Christianity (which one christian lord actually lead a revolt to protest the current Shogun’s treatment of Christians at the time) in the mix. It is like arguing that just because you live in America, you eat nothing but hamburgers. If anything, you guys should be making an argument from a Shin Taoist’s perspective (which I would like to hear) since Aikido is most closely associated with Shin Tao’s moral theories rather than a Buddhist one.

    If the entire society was completely devoid of self, there would be no wars… at least with the selfless society within itself (ignore the grammatical-logic contradiction). The waring states era in Japan was a giant civil war over which lord would control the region/country/wealth/culture/imperial palace of the time, and it lasted for hundreds of years. This was brought to an end by the Tokogowa Shogunate, for the most part, but at the time all of these lords that were fighting for supremacy were from Samaria families because those were the people in charge. They had entirely selfish reasons for making the people of their fief suffer and die for their ambition.

    You guys seem to be putting Samaria up on a pedestal, I don’t think that people are fundamentally different no matter where they were born or who raised them. Samaria were just as selfish, fearful, and vain as people today. The difference is the situation they were put in. As a Samaria, you couldn’t run away because your lord was your life’s blood. You had no place to run to, so it was an issue of dying in battle (where your memory would be honored, your family would be able to keep their status, and your wife and family would be taken car of) or dying in the woods of starvation (where you would be hunted like a dog by your friends and family, your wife would be sold to a brothel and children abandoned in the streets to starve, your family might loose standing with their lord and result in a pay cut for the whole clan). It was a like asking do you want to die or do you want to have a piece of cake and then die? Any way they go, they were expecting to die (the average age at the time in Japan during the waring states era was 25). I think even a westerner would make the same decision… any one would regardless of weather they thought they could win or not. They were however very well disciplined because of their circumstances, don’t get me wrong. I just don’t think that their mindset was necessarily all that different than a green beret’s or any other professional soldier class.

    As for confidence, I do agree with Jerry and MM, but I don’t think you are taking the argument far enough. Musashi Miamoto (one of the most famous Samaria of all time) claimed to have never bathed or combed his hair ever since his first duel at the age of 12 because he did not want to create an opening for an enemy to take. If anything, that says to me that he had absolutely no confidence in his skills if such a little thing like combing your hair will disrupt your focus.

  16. You are correct in that O’Sensei was not Buddhist. He was a follower of Onisaburo Deguchi, of the Omoto-Kyo, a Shinto sect.

    However, this conversation began with reference to The Seven Samurai, which is not about Aikido. Rather, it is about traditional Japanese swordplay, which is tied at the hip to Zen.

  17. I think I was trying to give a sense of what the ideals were, not the absolute objective reality of how people really behave and relate.
    Many societies have a set of ideals, then they have a set of non-ideals, and the reality falls somewhere between regardless of the culture I think.
    I only posted to shed light on both the ideals, and historical logic to why self confidence might not of been at the heart of the set of social ideals that manifested in Feudal Japan. I never said they manifested the way they did BECAUSE of Buddhism I mind you. I said their easy adaptation to Buddhism was a symptom of a preexisting social mentality.

  18. As regards to Miamoto; I wouldn’t attack, nor stand near a man who hadn’t bathed since junior high either. :p

  19. You know, there is a story (perhaps apocryphal) about O’Sensei and one of his students.

    The student, one of the instructors at Hombu, had his prize leather jacket stolen one day. The instructor, of course, was furious. He tried to find out who was at fault for not securing the dojo properly.

    Well, O’Sensei got wind of this and dropped by. The student was expecting O’Sensei to berate the students for not taking care of the dojo. Instead, and to the surprise of the instructor, O’Sensei laid the blame squarely on him, in front of the whole class.

    If he hadn’t attached so much importance to that leather jacket, there wouldn’t have been a problem in the first place. His desire created an opening, which allowed the dojo environment to be disrupted.

  20. an over-confident samurai gets owned in a duel, and opens the “existence” can of worms….hahahaha!

    i love this blog!!

  21. The motto of our dojo is “find your center.”

    I’m curious as to what you think that means, Jerry, MM, Incognito, others?

  22. Okay, I’ll bite.

    At the outset, I’d point out that this is a different topic than the Seven Samurai discussion. There, we were talking about the role of “self” in the context of traditional Japanese swordplay. My point there, in a nutshell: It is probably a mistake to assume a Western mindset when trying to understand how the Japanese viewed kenjutsu. The examples you gave, Tiger Woods, et. al., are simply inapposite.

    Specifically: in the context of a millisecond sword cut, the only rational judgment a sane person can make is “Now I am going to die.” Which is precisely how the Samurai viewed their art. (Thus the discussion of Zen).

    The question you are now asking is not about kenjutsu. Rather, and crucially, it is about Aikido, which is the difference between katsujinken, the life giving sword of budo, and satsujinken, the killing blade of bujutsu.

    Since according to O’Sensei Aikido is not dogmatic, (in any sense of the word), the “center” our motto refers to can mean something different to each of our students. It may mean something purely physical, or it may not. Your understanding of this is just as valid as mine.

    However, before this discussion devolves into something else, a gentle suggestion. To my mind, the interesting thing about our motto is not the noun “center”, but the transitive verb, “find”.

    Viewed this way, the point of our dojo becomes clear. It is a mutual, active process of students engaged in budo. It implies a journey, rather than a destination, and also connotes an open, curious mind.

    My two cents.

  23. The “center” as I interpret it is the same thing as my Qi coming from my Korean upbringing. It is where you draw your power, speed, and other ablilities that become heighted given that the situation calls for it. The difference I see between the two is the application, Qi in my opinion is more of a chaotic force, I’m inflicting massive physical damage, breaking concrete, blocking attacks. The Center I see as something more harmonic, since the concept of blending escapes me..

  24. And my 2 cents.

    I don’t think there is a differece between self and center. The idea that there is a diference is at the heart of the problem, and this discussion.

    We agree that your center is the one point of your balance and the personal source of your Ki, your Spirit, your essence, hence your power.

    We understand that we seek in Aikido and our dojo to “find” our center (and I like the “find” too). We usually begin with breathing and meditative routines to “become centered” and proceed into techniques that then harmonize our body, mind, and Spirit.

    I suggest that what we don’t agree on is the, why?

    I’m sure everyone has had the experience of performing in the “zone.” This is a state of effortless, semi-perfect performance, whether in Aikido, another sport, or anything you do. I think it’s our Western way of describing a state of centered activity. What is important to grasp is that in that state, the true self is performing on auto pilot because the ego has been subordinated and no “thought” is required or allowed.

    The ability to perform in the zone consistently is what defines greatness in any category, whether on the battlefield or the golf course. Thus, our samurai and Tiger Woods are very apt comparisons regardless of hemispherical orientation. Our samurai and TW are very aware of their ability to succeed (confident) because of their ability to stay focused-centered-in the zone, in the heat of the moment, what Hemingway referred to as Grace Under Pressure. Neither our samurai or TW would succeed if he believed he would die or lose before entering the fray.

    As aikidoka we accept that we will get cut in a knife fight, but not die. We are able to enter with confidence, believing without a doubt (centered) that we will subdue our attacker (and restore harmony to the universe).

    Sorry, that was way more than 2 cents.

  25. “Find you center” to me is refering to one’s personal space. Not the air, ground, and stuff around you, but rather the area in your life that you can controle. One’s life has many elements that no one person can controle all at once (that is why you don’t see many Noble prize winning football stars that become pop icons while in presidential office), and the maner in which a person managers their “space” or center determines how they live their life. Stressing one area could make one a musician, a gardener, or an athlete with sufficient effort. They just found a way to manage their center in such a way to make these goals a reality.

  26. Honestly, I can’t disagree with Buck as far as his comparison of Tiger Woods and a Samarai. A lot of Samarai did other arts like caligraphy, painting, music, dance, sports, and za-zen because they considered them to be the same kind of mental/physical training that they did with the sword. As in your story about the tea master and the Ronin, a master is a master. Musashi considered caligraphy to he equal to the use of a sword in value to a Samaria because they where “parts of a whole”.

  27. Where are you getting Samaria from? It sounds like an italian dish…

    “yes I would like the Samaria…with breadsticks please.”

  28. I’m not sure that “self” and “center” are necessarily equivalent, from an aiki perspective.

    “Self” is inward looking, focused on the ego. Taken to an extreme, it is a state that eschews any type of outward connection. By your definition, the more centered an Aikidoka, the more her behavior would tend towards sociopathy (or at least extreme narcissism).

    Is this really what O’Sensei wanted?

    I would define “center” more universally. I recall an illustration of Saotome Sensei where he is shown moving planets with his Aikido. That is what Aikido ought to be, and I think O’Sensei had a similar view.

    Have you read The Spiritual Foundations of Aikido by William Gleason? It gives a glimpse into what the Founder may have intended with his art. According to Gleason, O’Sensei saw Aikido as the physical form of the Shinto kotodama. Through practice, we would harmonize with this universal energy, and create a heaven on earth.

    So “center” takes on a deeper meaning. Not just my point of balance, or even my partner’s point of balance, “center” means something else entirely, a universal point of balance to which we are striving. It is an outward looking concept, and (quite frankly) gives deep meaning to the concept of “connection.”

  29. Well the term “self” is a term commonly used in philosophy as a grading term. Example: compare how Objectivism defines the role and perspective of “self” versus Christianity. When I used self at least I was speaking of a grading term that is applied to all ideologies within philosophy to show contrast in thinking and processes within those ideologies.

    Center is a term that is very Martial to me however.

  30. im not thinking about moving planets when i do aikido.

    you, a threat, must be neutralized…that is my thinking of things

  31. The dumb butt in Seven Samurai died because he was emotionally distracted and way too tense.

    Buck, I disagree with your idea of center and spirit, “the zone”, and you and Jerry’s “restoring harmony to the universe”. My “spirit” isn’t in my center. “The zone” you are referring to sounds like the point after you have practiced some skill to such an extent that it becomes instinct. Instinct does indeed require thought. Subduing an attacker without creating injury won’t restore harmony to the universe as a whole.

    Jerry, I question your tea man story. What would have happened if they actually dueled it out? It looks like a big bluff to me. Anyone can appear that they have it together.

    MM:”Christians hope to live forever”- Are you kidding? We are living forever. Which “Bible college” did you/are you attending?

  32. For me, “find your center” is entirely physical. Christians don’t need aikido’s centering philosophy to live God-pleasing lives, and they certainly don’t need it for anything spiritual.

  33. Grasshopper, remember that aikido literally means the way of harmonizing spirit. The fundamental purpose of our practice is not to perfect iriminage, but to harmonize our spirit, which in aikido terms does eminate from our physical center, with our minds and bodies and with the world around us. That is where peace and love unfold, according to the founder.

    I don’t think you have to agree with or understand everything O’Sensei believed to practice in the spirit of aikido; he was devoted to a pretty obscure and esoteric sect of shintoism as I understand it. Everyone finds their own meaning and magic in their aikido. Nevertheless, by his design, the act of practicing aikido itself, without a conscious belief, kindles and focuses your ki and brings it into harmony with your own mind and body, with uke’s, with the classes’, and with the world’s.

    I think this is why aikido dojos are in general friendly, peaceful, supportive, loving places. Everyone who is a member of our dojo comes from a different walk of life with different backgrounds, ideas, and experiences. Yet somehow we all get along very well without fights on the mat, angry words, jealousy, and the usulal trappings of ego that often come with a martial art. I think this is aikido at work and one of the main reasons I love aikido and our dojo. After 14 years, it is a beautiful thing to witness, unfolding as we train, regardless of our intentions. Thank you O’Sensei!

Comments are closed.