The right reasons include, but are not limited to:
1. You want to become really good at Aikido.
2. You want to some day teach Aikido.
3. You are seeking a path to enlightenment. (Not sure what this means, but it seems like a good reason).
4. You love Aikido and want to prove to yourself how dedicated you can be.
5. You want to learn to have an open mind and a heart for service.
3. Enlightenment. I suppose it depends on what kind of enlightenment, and what kind of person you are; or rather, want to be.
What a great post Tonya. You’ve hit on something profound with #5.
Are all of these your main reasons for going up to N.Y.?
Which is your reason?
My guess: some combination of all five.
Thanks for class, Jerry.
You’re welcome. I wonder if incogneto and MM enjoyed the seminar at Sand Drift.
Do you think MM wore her hakama?
yes that was a good class. I’m glad i was able to share some insight
More than good insight, it helps me resolve a thorny issue. Thanks.
I’m sorry to say that we did not attend the sanddrift seminar. I wanted to, but MM had just gotten to the point to where she could walk around two days before because of her back. Didn’t want to risk an injury, so we took the day off. Bad timing… not that there is a good time to get injured.
Is there class tonight? The calendar is blank for monday.
Incognito, what are you talking about? The schedule has John and me teaching tonight. Although, I may train in the second class and let Jerry teach.
Sorry, My attention shifted to next monday because it is highlighted. (I thought Memorial day was yesterday for some reason…)
This blog is dead…spinning the discussion wheel!!!
Pins vs. Throws….
ready
set
GO!
Perhaps pins are for detaining (law enforcement teaches much more brutal pins than ours), and throws are for fleeing.
Perhaps, to take it a step further, pins would be practical if you’re dealing with someone close, such as a family member, or one attacker. Throws might be more practical for multiple attackers. But I think after throwing one, that may be good enough a distraction to FLEE.
Strikes turn into grabs, which turn into throws, which turn into pins.
It’s a continuum–they are just points of contact. The distinctions are not important…only that nage affect uke’s center. And vice versa.
BTW, the new USAF newsletter is out. Our grand opening seminar slideshow is featured.
Oh yeah, you might find this interesting. Pre-war Aikido, and I guess aikijujitsu also, had these finishing moves after the pin. You had to demonstrate control (with your hands free), and then you finished off uke.
hmm that is interesting jerry.
So even if my intent all day long is to grab you, it’s still a strike-turned-grab? Ikkyo is a throw?
I wish I could have seen pre-war aikido.
Google Gozo Shiodo Sensei for some pre-war Aikido.
The funny thing is, you already *know* the finishing movements–it is already there in our practice.
For example, the nikkyo pin. What does nage do after uke taps out? He folds the arm back and uses his shin to keep the arm pinned while he stands up. During this movement his hands are free. The only thing missing is drawing the blade and finishing uke off.
It is how you demonstrated the formal pin during your tests. Now you know where it comes from!
They are functionally the same, grassHopper, in that uke wants to control nage’s center, while nage wants to control uke’s center.
For example, rather than grab the lead hand, a swordsman could choose to strike the hand. Joel taught me a bokken technique that strikes uke’s hand after a “do” cut. The entrance is irimi-tenkan, to nage’s front. He learned it from kendo. (You’ve seen it before).
I’ve seen ikkyo turned into a throw. Lane Sensei had me demonstrate several sankyo throws on my 1st kyu test.
BTW, a little birdie told me that our host will be taking her 1st kyu test next month.
If you were trying the keep this secret…sorry! 🙂
Bird?! Where? They eat our kind, you know..
Hey,
Yeah, we didn’t make it to Sandrift…. I’m still getting over an injury. I have my hakama however… I’ve worn it around the apartment gleefully. It is a darker blue than I expected. *worries her butt looks big*
Go Tonya!! ^_^
It’s hovering over your left shoulder right now, grassHopper….
*throw’s an explosive Batarang turning the bird into a puff of smoke*
no more bird…
I’d say 1, 4, and 5 are my main reasons.
When it’s three that matters…
Why